Home

Previous Entry | Next Entry

Historical Research

  • Feb. 7th, 2008 at 1:58 PM
Madame de Jurjewicz
Last summer at Clarion, I had the joy of instructing 19 fabulous students whose instructors also included Karen Joy Fowler, a writer and person I really admire. (Her best-known novel is The Jane Austen Book Club, but my favorite is The Sweetheart Season. And her short stories are pure genius.) We're all still on an e-mailing list, and interesting stuff comes up sometimes - this exchange was so useful I thought I'd share it with the Populace:

Former Student: I'm working on a period piece and have been doing some fascinating research at the library - the San Francisco Chronicle dates back to the mid 1800s and it's ALL on microfilm. It's giving me a lot of great details, especially the ads and the classified sections. But it's all written in formal journalist style.
I was wondering what resources might be good for learning the everyday, boring details of life in these periods. For example, if I was sitting in a trolley in 1903 and overheard a 22-year-old woman chatting with a friend, how would she speak? What would she be talking about? What would she wear and smell like? What would they eat at lunch? Where are they going and why?
Any tips?
KJF: I did a lot of this for SISTER NOON. Great fun!
Some of the things I did, in addition to the fascinating but very head-ache inducing newspapers on microfiche: try to figure out what people were reading. My book was in 1890 and Dickens was serializing one of his novels -- I forget which. There were Conan Doyles, I think. And then books I'd never heard of. But someone in a trolley can always be talking about a book, and reading books that were published at the time or a little earlier are great sources for what people were wearing and maybe how they talked (if novels are reliable guides to that.)
The newspapers are great sources of the day's scandals. In 1890, the Chronicle was full of the mysterious murders in Whitehall and the tragedy at Wounded Knee. There was a doomsday cult. There was a mysterious disease afflicting the horses. People like to talk about shocking events.
I believe there were some magazines I was able to see at the State Library. The public library in San Francisco has a good history room.
Choose one or two or three or four of the famous people from your period and read their biographies. They don't even have to be local to San Fran to give you a sense of things. Pick an area: medicine, art, politics, and research what was happening specific to that.

Student: Karen - wow, lots of great suggestions! Thank you so much! I didn't think about magazines or biographies of the time. Or that (of course) they would be discussing books and scandals on the trolley. Probably local plays, too. Lots of ads in the paper for theatre, so that would be fairly easy to explore. And I hear you on the eyestrain. I'm still amazed that so much is on microfiche, but good lord.
That said, this research is so much fun, and so easily distracting. It tickles me what made the front page in 1901 - celebrity gossip! Here's an interesting tidbit: on Feb 4, 1901 (as reported in the following day's paper), Carrie Nation got arrested in Topeka after sparking a street brawl in which her cheek got cut with her own axe. Sarah Bernhardt was accosted by yet another gentleman selling life insurance and finally capitulated, buying a policy that would augment her son's $20,000/year allowance considerably in the event of her demise. And a fresh face made her New York stage debut - Ethel Barrymore, featured in a charming comedy that won the hearts of local critics. All of this reported on the front page, above the fold.
Delia - sounds like you both agree on novels from that period. Beautiful suggestion, as is the one about memoirs. I can practically smell the musty bunny now. Do you think memoirs would be skewed toward an upper class perspective? That wouldn't be a problem, necessarily, since that's the class I'm writing about.

Delia: Memoirs are, of course, written by people who have leisure, education, and publishing contacts. In 1901, that would pretty much have been the upper classes, plus artists and politicians and other public figures who were literarily inclined. The thing you have to remember about memoirs is that memory is selective and those who want to set the record straight in public often lie. I've read memoirs of famous 19th c. courtesans that were purer invention than most modern autobiographical novels. What's interesting about them is what the kinds of lies they tell in public reveal about the society they lived in.

Other Former Student: If you want to try sparing yourself the microfilm, there are a couple of good online sources with tons of newspapers. . Newsbank seems to only have 1970 and later. Access.NewspaperArchive.com has papers going back into the 1700's. Your library probably has a link on their website you can follow to get access using your library card #.

Hope this is helpful!

Tags:

Comments

[info]krismcd59 wrote:
Feb. 7th, 2008 07:25 pm (UTC)
They're not period resources, but Daniel Pool's "What Jane Austen Ate and Charles Dickens Knew," and "Dicken's Fur Coat and Charlotte's Unanswered Letters" are terrific introductions to the manners and morals of the 19th century -- he offers glossaries and extensive bibliographies too. I would also read the popular plays (drawing-room comedies will have the most fashionable dialogue) of the time period as well as college literary journals and newspapers for slang and wit of the time.
[info]sartorias wrote:
Feb. 7th, 2008 08:25 pm (UTC)
He makes a lot of errors, though, alas.
[info]vcmw wrote:
Feb. 7th, 2008 07:42 pm (UTC)
Books of published correspondence can be very interesting too - though with most of the same caveats as those about memoirs, I suppose. But the writing style might be a little less formal in the letters?
[info]oracne wrote:
Feb. 7th, 2008 08:06 pm (UTC)
Since she's looking at records of a city, she should see if the library has old telephone directories (mine has them on microfiche). These are great resources for finding out what businesses there were, and where they were located. Here are some notes I took: http://oracne.livejournal.com/269483.html

It's also worth trying to find a maps archive--I went to the Free Library of Philadelphia, and found maps of trolley routes and also insurance maps, which label the businesses and distinguish them from private homes. The maps helped a lot for figuring out what neighborhoods were like during certain spans of time.

I just suggested a panel on historical research for WisCon!
[info]deliasherman wrote:
Feb. 8th, 2008 02:50 am (UTC)
Can I play, too? I love doing panels on historical research. It allows my inner Research Geek a chance to come out and play.
[info]oracne wrote:
Feb. 8th, 2008 02:00 pm (UTC)
If this panel works like it did last time I suggested it, I won't get to be on it, but a lot of cooler people will, so that's likely!
[info]gaedhal wrote:
Feb. 7th, 2008 08:32 pm (UTC)
I love diaries. There are published ones that are great,
but you can also find unpublished ones, both in your local
library and historical association -- and in your own
family.

My mother gave me her diaries for two years -- 1942 and 1944 --
and they really show a picture of everyday life that's natural,
but also so instructive of what it felt like to be living
during WW2. What people ate (rationing was in force), how they
traveled (on the train), what movies they watched and what
radio shows they listened to, what they did on dates (a huge
part of what my mother wrote about, including dates with my
future father!), even how they shopped. My mother was not a
writer by any means, but she wrote this and to me it's not
only a valuable resource, it's a picture into HER.
[info]coloredink wrote:
Feb. 7th, 2008 10:30 pm (UTC)
And of course, if you're on LiveJournal, [info]little_details will surely know the answer to the question. :)
[info]ellen_kushner wrote:
Feb. 8th, 2008 02:51 am (UTC)
Wow - thank you for this, from all of us!
[info]sararyan wrote:
Feb. 7th, 2008 11:02 pm (UTC)
This is great, thanks for posting it. And I hadn't known about Little Details, either: I joined immediately!
[info]dichroic wrote:
Feb. 7th, 2008 11:26 pm (UTC)
Not just memoirs, there are all kinds of books about living in a city at a particular time. Two I like for Philadelphia in my grandmother's childhood, for instance, are Christopher Morley's Philadelphia (essays about walking around city neighborhoods in the 1920s) and Lloyd Alexander's The Gawgon and the Boy, about a few months when he was 11.
[info]mouseworks wrote:
Feb. 8th, 2008 02:07 am (UTC)
Smaller newspapers
I got a tremendous insight into the 1910 through 1920 period in rural Virginia but also in general for the time by reading a local paper, including the letters to the editor. I picked up little things like before 1918, people moved to other rural areas (one letter was "The Dark Side of the Dakotas"), but after people moved to cities. Kids eloped from the boarding school; people got cut in fights at parties. A black woman bootlegger described as the widow of a white man killed a white man for laughing at her when she asked him to pay.

The other thing was poking around in the National Archives. People writing marginalia and comments on reports tended to use more casual language. You'll be tapping a more educated and more elite group with that, but reports from agents tailing suspected German spies and reports from spies on the Comintern and how Lenin wasn't for Indian Independence despite what J. E. Hoover and the Brits thought are neat to see on the original paper.

The other thing to do is look at census reports for an area -- the Cherokee had people whose last names were things like "White Man Killer."
[info]julieandrews wrote:
Feb. 8th, 2008 06:30 pm (UTC)
My library also has high school yearbooks going back about a century. If you want to get an idea of what teenagers were up to back before there was such a thing as teenagers. :)

Just the names and photos might give you ideas for characters.
[info]klages wrote:
Feb. 8th, 2008 08:52 pm (UTC)
If your period is after 1895 or so, postcards are wonderful. Pretty pictures on the front (often showing buildings and neighborhoods in great detail), and real people's actual comments on the back. (One of my favorites was a PC of a very fancy hotel, and on the back was "Room small and dirty. Home Tues. Love, Frank."

Told me more about that hotel than anything "officially" published ever could.
[info]madwriter wrote:
Feb. 12th, 2008 09:28 pm (UTC)
You may have to pay for it, but I do believe the New York Times has archived itself online all the way back to the 1850's.